Field Note 03: Stop Calling Everything Luxury


Hello everyone,

First off, thank you for the incredible response to Field Note 02: Partnership Season Is Open. I loved hearing your thoughts and swapping notes on standout brand collabs. More of that energy, please.

Now, onto this week’s mini rant.

Last weekend, while trying to escape Milan’s 35°C heat (San Pellegrino in hand, of course), I wandered into a bookshop and spotted a book on selling luxury. The subtitle read: “Lessons from Lexus, the Four Seasons...” and I didn’t even finish reading it. My brain immediately went: Here we go again.

Not to pick on Lexus (or Apple, or BMW, or Aesop, or Canada Goose for that matter) but can we stop calling premium brands “luxury”?

They’re not the same thing. They never were.

So let’s set the record straight.

Premium vs. Luxury: The Breakdown

  1. Function vs. Symbolism
    Premium is about features, quality, and value at a higher price.
    Luxury? It’s about status, heritage, emotion, and meaning. Often totally irrational. And that’s the point.
  2. Objective vs. Subjective Value
    Premium can be justified logically.
    Luxury defies logic. It’s desire, culture, legacy. It doesn’t need to make sense.
  3. Marketing Logic
    Premium plays by the rules: segment, target, position.
    Luxury creates its own universe. It doesn’t follow demand. It creates it.
  4. Price Elasticity
    Premium has a ceiling.
    Luxury pricing is elastic. In fact, higher prices = higher desirability.
  5. Accessibility
    Premium wants more people to access better value.
    Luxury thrives on being out of reach. Financially, socially, even emotionally.

So yes, an Apple Watch is premium tech. But it’s not Audemars Piguet. BMW is brilliant engineering. But it’s not Rolls-Royce.

Bottom line: once something becomes “reasonable,” it stops being luxury. And that’s the point, luxury isn’t meant to make sense. It’s meant to stir something within us.

If you're interested in this topic, I highly recommend you read The Luxury Strategy: Break the Rules of Marketing to Build Luxury Brands by Jean-Noël Kapferer and Vincent Bastien. I read it in 2013 and still refer to it when clients want to elevate their positioning. It's a must.

What I'm Into Right Now:

📚 Books: Never Split the Difference - Negotiating as if your Life Depended on it, by Chris Voss

Upcoming Travel Plans:

28 & 29 June:

📍 Geneva, Switzerland for the Bonhams Cars: The Bonmont Sales

2 & 3 July:

📍 London, UK for the Grand Prix Ball 2025

If you’ll be in town, at the same event, or just want to grab a coffee (or a cocktail), get in touch.

Currently Working On:

If your interested in joining the fun as participant or as a partner, hit reply and let's chat. It's going to be an unforgettable weekend! 🚗💨💨

Thanks for reading.

(Full Disclaimer: as you can see, there’s some travel on the calendar… so Field Note 04 might be a little late. But it’ll be worth the wait.)

Zantelle

P.S. Know someone who'd be interested in this? Hit forward, or they can subscribe here.

Zantelle van der Linde

I track how luxury moves through culture, capital, and technology. I run NEON NAVY and lead marketing at Viperium. These Field Notes are where I think out loud: client work, market shifts, things worth noting. Written from Cape Town, Milan, Dubai, or wherever the work takes me.

Read more from Zantelle van der Linde

Field Notes has a new home. If you've landed here from an old link, welcome. And thank you for finding your way back. Field Notes has moved to Beehiiv, where it has a fresh new look, a new online archive, and a better reading experience all round. All 14 issues are waiting for you there, and Field Note 15 is on its way very soon. READ FIELD NOTES ON BEEHIIV See you on the other side. Zantelle

Hello everyone, 2024 was the year I established NEON NAVY. In most cases, a fairly regular administrative process of registering a business and opening a bank account. Not in my case. As a South African citizen and Italian resident, it took me eight months to find a solution that ticked all my boxes. And in those eight months, countless calls with lawyers, accountants, tax advisors, wealth managers and financial managers discussing every possible fiscal and tax setup imaginable. It was not...

Hello everyone, For those of you who have been reading my Field Notes for a while, you might recall that alongside my consultancy work at NEON NAVY, I also hold the role of Chief Marketing Officer at Viperium. As a soon-to-be-launched cryptocurrency, $VPR forms part of the wider Viperium ecosystem and towards the end of last year, this took us to Singapore to attend TOKEN2049, the largest cryptocurrency conference in the world. It was fascinating to see the range of projects already live, or...